Old Fashioned Candy
|

Old Fashioned Candy: History, Flavors & Brands

Snack History Nostalgia RatingPure nostalgia
5/5

Quick answer: Old fashioned candies still sold today include Necco Wafers (1847), Cracker Jack (1896), Abba Zaba (1920s) and Cow Tales (1980s). Of the featured candies, only Canada’s Cherry Blossom has been discontinued, in 2025.

Remembering old fashioned candy is indeed a great way to take you back to the 20th century and remind you of who you were. Why? Because candy often brings back memories of our loved ones and happy times.

Do you recall how we used to save up our nickels to buy candy necklaces at the pharmacy? Or you may remember the candy dish that Nana always had on the counter with the cinnamon bears in it. Or maybe your father loved the Zero Bars? 

Let’s travel back in time and explore old fashioned candy that has been loved for decades.

Old Fashioned CandyFacts
Introduced1847 (Necco Wafers); 1920s (Abba Zaba); 1896 (Cracker Jack); 1980s (Cow Tales)
ManufacturerVarious: Spangler (Necco Wafers), Goetze Candy Company, Annabelle Candy Co., Frito-Lay
Candy TypeAssorted: wafers, caramel chews, taffy bars, caramel popcorn, toffee, candy sticks
Original FlavorsNecco: orange, lemon, lime, clove, chocolate, cinnamon, licorice, wintergreen
Still AvailableYes, all featured candies except Cherry Blossom (discontinued 2025) remain available
Country of OriginUnited States (Cherry Blossom: Canada; Mackintosh’s Toffee: England)
Parent CompanyCracker Jack owned by Frito-Lay; Abba Zaba by Annabelle Candy Co.; Cow Tales by Goetze Candy Company
Notable Cultural ReferenceAbba Zaba featured in the movie Half Baked; Cracker Jack referenced in baseball culture

Old Fashioned Candy Timeline

  • 1847 — Necco Wafers introduced using original recipe still used today.
  • 1896 — Cracker Jack officially named; Goetze Candy Company founded (1895).
  • 1902 — Company reorganized as Rueckheim Bros. & Eckstein; it became The Cracker Jack Company in 1922.
  • 1913 — Explorer Donald MacMillan brought Necco Wafers to the Arctic.
  • 1917 — Sam Altshuler immigrated to America from Russia.
  • 1920s — Abba Zaba candy bar introduced (first made by Colby and McDermott in 1922; later by Cardinet Candy Co.).
  • 1930s — 2.5 tons of Necco Wafers transported on South Pole expedition.
  • 1950 — Annabelle Candy Co. founded by Sam Altshuler in San Francisco.
  • 1978 — Annabelle Candy Co. acquired Cardinet Candy Co. and Abba Zaba.
  • 1980s — Cow Tales introduced by Goetze Candy Company.
Old Fashioned Candy Timeline infographic with key facts and major dates
Old Fashioned Candy Timeline

Old Fashioned Candy vs Sugar Daddy

FeatureOld Fashioned CandySugar Daddy
TextureChewy caramel with cream center (Cow Tales) or crisp wafers (Necco)Hard caramel lollipop
IntroducedAs early as 1847 (Necco Wafers)1925
ManufacturerVarious: Spangler (Necco), Goetze, Annabelle Candy Co., Frito-LayTootsie Roll Industries
FlavorsMultiple: caramel, chocolate, vanilla, fruit, wafer varietiesOriginal caramel
Price RangeBudget-friendly, typically under $2 per unitBudget-friendly, typically under $1 per unit
AvailabilityWidely available in specialty candy shops and onlineAvailable in select stores and online
Nostalgia FactorStrong; tied to Civil War, baseball, and childhood memoriesStrong; classic American retro candy icon
Old Fashioned Candy vs Sugar Daddy comparison infographic: launch year, maker, flavors and more
Old Fashioned Candy vs Sugar Daddy

Names of Old Fashioned Candy

  1. Necco Wafers
  2. Cow Tales
  3. Abba Zaba
  4. Cracker Jacks
  5. Cherry Blossom
  6. Popeye Candy Sticks
  7. Charleston Chew
  8. Mackintosh Toffee
Graphic listing old fashioned candy names, featuring Necco Wafers

Top 8 Old Fashioned Candy

1. Necco Wafers

Necco Wafers, the classic chalky wafer candy rolls
NECCO WAFERS

Candy lovers have been enjoying the simple and delicious retro candy known as Necco Wafers since 1847. The same recipe from 1847 is being used to make Necco Wafers today. The savory flavors of orange, lemon, lime, clove, chocolate, cinnamon, licorice, and wintergreen come to mind. A pioneering old fashioned candy, they’re a favorite among children and adults. 

The Necco Wafers’ original recipe has practically not been altered throughout the years because of their continuing appeal. The eight most popular tastes and colors are back, including brown chocolate, licorice, which is dark gray; light purple clove; yellow lemon; green lime; orange, obviously orange; white cinnamon; and pink wintergreen.

READ MORE:  Candy Mascots: History, Brands & Trivia

Seven of the eight tastes were created to be exact replicas of their original counterparts. Due to a modest modification in the cooking process, true Necco Wafers lovers may notice a deeper cocoa flavor in the chocolate wafers. 

Since their invention, Necco Wafers have literally been loved all over the world. During the Civil War, troops carried them. Necco Wafers were brought by explorer Donald MacMillan in 1913 and shared with Eskimo children while he was exploring the Arctic. Later in the 1930s, 2.5 tons of Necco Wafers were transported on an expedition to the South Pole.

2. Cow Tales

Cow Tales, chewy caramel sticks with a cream center
COW TALES

A distinctive old fashioned candy from the 1980s is called Cow Tales. A cream center is encircled by a chewy and delectable caramel. Cow Tales are available in four delicious flavors: strawberry, caramel apple, vanilla, and chocolate. The famed Goetze Candy Company, founded in 1895, is the manufacturer of Cow Tales.

Many people wonder why Goetze’s Candy Company chose the moniker “Cow Tales” instead of “Cow Tails” for these candies. Since Goetze’s is a more modern and jovial version of Caramel Creams, they chose “Tales” rather than “Tails” to allude to the whimsical and nostalgic nature of children’s bedtime stories. Early packaging included a cow leaping over the moon in a reference to the “Hey Diddle Diddle” children’s song, highlighting Goetze’s decision to use “Tales” rather than “Tails.”

3. Abba Zaba

Hand holding an Abba-Zaba taffy bar with peanut butter in checkered wrapper
ABBA ZABA

A bar of creamy peanut butter-filled vanilla taffy that is chewy and elastic is known as Abba Zaba. They are quite addicting. The movie Half Baked, in which the character Scarface calls Abba Zaba his only friend, has lately increased awareness of Abba Zaba.

Abba Zaba is a highly popular old fashioned candy that has been around since the 1920s. It is tasty and has endured the test of time.

🍭 0/0

Annabelle Candy Co., Inc. was established in 1950 by Sam Altshuler, a Russian immigrant who came to America in 1917. After years of developing his formula and mastering the art of candy manufacturing, he eventually found success with his Rocky Road candy bar. He started making Rocky Road in San Francisco and named his company the Annabelle Candy Company after his daughter. 

The product, which is presently listed among the top-selling chocolate bars on the West Coast, soon acquired popularity throughout the western United States, where it has the strongest grip. The Cardinet Candy Co., which produced the Abba Zaba candy bar, was bought by Annabelle in 1978.

What began as a family business is still going strong today as a privately held American candy producer, producing some of the most well-known and iconic West Coast products on the market.

4. Cracker Jacks

Bag of The Original Cracker Jack caramel coated popcorn and peanuts
CRACKER JACKS

You may be sure that every delectable Cracker Jack bite will bring back pleasant memories. Old fashioned candy called Cracker Jack consists of crunchy peanuts and caramel-coated popcorn with a hint of a molasses taste. It is a traditional and well-liked delicacy that still comes with a prize inside each box, although the toy prize was replaced by a digital code in 2016. 

Previously known as candied popcorn and peanuts, the snack was given the formal name Cracker Jack in 1896. In 1922, the business changed its name once more to become The Cracker Jack Company.

Frito-Lay is the manufacturer of Cracker Jacks today. At baseball games, they continue to be popular favorites and continue to enchant both young people and adults. Therefore, even though the prizes may have changed over time, you can be sure that the candy inside hasn’t.

READ MORE:  Hard Candy: History, Flavors & Brands

5. Cherry Blossom

Cherry Blossom candy, a classic Canadian chocolate cherry treat
CHERRY BLOSSOM

One of the most popular candies in Canada is cherry blossom. maraschino cherry in a delicious bite, with coconut, toasted peanuts, and, of course, chocolate all around. A really old fashioned candy delicacy, Cherry Blossom has been loved for well over 100 years.

The Walter M. Lowney firm was established by its proprietor and namesake, Walter M. Lowney, in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1883. Lowney’s business established a branch in Canada in the middle of the 1890s, and by 1905 it had a factory running out of Montreal. 

The Cherry Blossom expanded along with Lowney’s business as the 20th century went on. Contrary to common perception, no injections are made into the cherry blossoms inside. A coating of the invertase enzyme covers the chocolate, encasing the cherries. This layer then remains on the cherries for one or two weeks before becoming liquid.

In 1987, Hershey Canada acquired Lowney and started producing Cherry Blossoms as a subsidiary brand, moving production to its Smiths Falls plant in 1989. With a constantly identifiable name, Cherry Blossoms were sold at grocery shops, dollar stores, and gas stations throughout the country until Hershey discontinued them in 2025.

6. Popeye Candy Sticks

Popeye candy sticks, an old fashioned candy cigarette treat
POPEYE CANDY STICKS

Popeye Candy Sticks are a classic, old-fashioned candy that can always make us feel young at heart if you’re looking for something crunchy, sweet, and powdery. Since they were first produced in the late 19th century, they are also known as “candy cigarettes” and have gained a lot of popularity.

However, because of the widespread belief that they encouraged young people to smoke and become adult smokers, these sweets were eventually banned in a number of countries, though they remain legal in the US. Candy Sticks, a similar version produced by World Candies, had cartoon character pictures on the packaging as opposed to looking like cigarette packs like the earlier product did. 

There are boxes with characters like Spider-Man and Popeye, as well as Warner Bros. properties such as DC Superheroes, Scooby-Doo, and The Flintstones.

7. Charleston Chew

Charleston Chew bar in yellow wrapper above the unwrapped chocolate-covered nougat bar
CHARLESTON CHEW

Old fashioned candy known as “Charleston Chew” has been around since 1922, when the “Charleston” dance became increasingly popular among young people. You can enjoy the tasty old fashioned candy flavor of the Charleston Chew bar even if you aren’t old enough to remember it or can’t perform the Charleston dance. 

This old fashioned candy was initially created in 1922 by the Fox-Cross Candy Company. The initial confection from this Cambridge, Massachusetts-based business was a milk chocolate-covered nougat with vanilla flavoring. This confection that comprehends the emotions of the moment is just absolutely fantastic. Consuming it feels hip and enjoyable, and it also livens up your typical sweets habit. Consider how the Charleston Chew’s arrival in town must have made the populace of the 1920s feel. 

Over time, the taste profiles grew to include flavors like chocolate and strawberry nougat. At one point, there was even a banana flavor. However, only the vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry flavors are still available, along with the little chews. The ability to somewhat personalize this confectionery, like the dance, is one of its best features. While some prefer to eat theirs frozen, others prefer to consume them at room temperature. You ought to carry it out however you see fit.

8. Mackintosh Toffee

Mackintosh's Mack Toffee, a classic Canadian toffee bar candy
MACKINTOSH TOFFEE

One of the greatest old-fashioned candy Canada has ever had is Mackintosh Toffee — rich and creamy vintage toffee that is smooth and just the right amount of sweet. Since it has been around since 1890, Macintosh Toffee is a traditional, retro candy treat.

The idea for Mackintosh’s Toffee, which is neither too hard nor too soft, originated soon after John Mackintosh opened his confectionery in Halifax, Yorkshire, England, in 1890. Rowntree Mackintosh, formed in 1969 by the merger of rivals Mackintosh and Rowntree, was taken over by Nestlé in 1988. It is frequently said that the product is over 100 years old.

READ MORE:  Yumearth: History, Ingredients & Products

The toffee is sold in bags that have a haphazard collection of individually wrapped flavor toffees. The flavors include malt (blue), harrogate (yellow), mint (green), egg and cream (orange), coconut (pink), and toffee (maroon). In order to mask the strong flavor of the town’s therapeutic waters, confectioners in the Yorkshire spa town of Harrogate created the flavor Harrogate.

Bottom Line – Old Fashioned Candy

Candy is an inseparable part of our lives. We have enjoyed sweet treats since childhood, which is why they are associated with happiness and loved ones. That is why we decided to bring your sweet memories to the surface by reminding you of some of the most famous old fashioned candy. Above, you will find retro candy brands that managed to endure the test of time, and many of them are still manufactured today. 

Frequently Asked Questions about Old Fashioned Candy

What are some examples of old fashioned candy still available today?

Many classic old fashioned candies remain available today, including Necco Wafers, Cow Tales, Abba Zaba, Cracker Jack, and Charleston Chew. These candies have endured for decades and can be found in specialty candy shops and online retailers. Their lasting popularity is a testament to their timeless appeal.

Why is Abba Zaba candy so well known?

Abba Zaba is a beloved old fashioned candy that has been around since the 1920s, featuring chewy vanilla taffy filled with creamy peanut butter. Its fame was boosted more recently by the movie Half Baked, in which the character Scarface famously calls Abba Zaba his only friend. The Annabelle Candy Company has produced it since acquiring Cardinet Candy Co. in 1978.

What is the history behind Necco Wafers?

Necco Wafers have been enjoyed since 1847 and are made using the same original recipe to this day, making them one of the oldest candies in America (production paused after Necco closed in 2018 until Spangler revived them in 2020). They come in eight classic flavors including chocolate, licorice, clove, lemon, lime, orange, cinnamon, and wintergreen. Their historical reach is remarkable, having been carried by Civil War soldiers and brought on expeditions to both the Arctic and South Pole.

Why is the candy called Cow Tales instead of Cow Tails?

Goetze's Candy Company intentionally chose the spelling 'Tales' rather than 'Tails' to reflect the whimsical and nostalgic nature of children's bedtime stories. This playful nod was further emphasized by early packaging that featured a cow jumping over the moon, referencing the classic 'Hey Diddle Diddle' nursery rhyme. It distinguished Cow Tales as a fun and imaginative treat rather than just a caramel candy.

Who manufactures Cracker Jack today and what makes it old fashioned?

Cracker Jack is currently manufactured by Frito-Lay and has been a beloved snack since being officially named in 1896. It consists of caramel-coated popcorn and peanuts with a hint of molasses flavor, and each box still contains a prize inside, though since 2016 it has been a digital code rather than a toy. It remains especially popular at baseball games, continuing a tradition that has delighted generations of fans.

Who makes Necco Wafers now?

Necco Wafers are now made by Spangler. They were introduced in 1847 and are still made with the original recipe.

Who makes Abba Zaba?

Abba Zaba is made by Annabelle Candy Co., founded by Sam Altshuler in San Francisco in 1950, which acquired the bar in 1978.

Related Posts

  • Aero Chocolate Bar

    Aero Chocolate Bar: History, Flavors & Packaging

    Snack History Nostalgia RatingPure nostalgia ★★★★★5/5 Quick answer: The Aero bar was introduced in 1935 by Rowntree’s in the United Kingdom as an aerated…

    Read more

  • Kosher Candy

    Kosher Candy: History, Brands & Ingredients

    Snack History Nostalgia RatingBig on nostalgia ★★★★★4/5 Quick answer: Kosher candy is candy made under Jewish dietary laws that are over 3,000 years old…

    Read more

  • Moser Roth Chocolate

    Moser Roth Chocolate: History, Brands & Facts

    Snack History Nostalgia RatingBig on nostalgia ★★★★★4/5 Quick answer: Moser Roth chocolate traces back to 1841, when Wilhelm Roth Jr. opened the Roth business…

    Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *